A broken Early Access embarrassment reborn as one of the most terrifying co-op games of the year. When No More Room in Hell 2 hit Early Access in October 2024, it was a review-bombed disaster — janky, buggy, and barely playable. The 1.0 launch is a different game, and this is a Re-Sniff to match: Torn Banner turned one of 2024's ugliest launches into one of 2026's best co-op zombie experiences. The dread here is unmatched. The gunplay underneath it is the only thing keeping it out of the top tier.
There's no traditional narrative — you deploy as an emergency Responder into zombie-infested locations, link up with up to seven other survivors, and complete objectives to aid humanity's survival. What replaces plot is situation: the constant, grinding pressure of infection, scarce supplies, and the knowledge that a single bite can end a run you've sunk an hour into. It leans on decades of zombie history — the DNA of Left 4 Dead's co-op and State of Decay's survival dread are both here — but filters them through a bleakness that's all its own.
The standout, and the thing every review circles, is the atmosphere. Load into Objective mode and the first thing that hits you is the quiet — no swelling music to warn you of danger, no glowing waypoint dragging you to the next task. Just environmental design selling the fact that the zombies have come and could be anywhere. You often start alone on a large map, scavenging and sneaking, and have to actually find your fellow survivors. It generates tension almost no other co-op shooter reaches.
The survival systems back it up: avoiding infection, conserving supplies, and coordinating with a squad of eight make the survivors feel like actual fragile humans rather than action heroes. The 1.0 update added a Survival wave-defense mode that's a great pick-up-and-play change of pace, plus new maps, progression paths, and thousands of fixes.
The persistent weakness is the shooting. The gunplay and melee feel weak — subpar next to the games it's channeling — and it's the main thing keeping the moment-to-moment from matching the atmosphere around it. Zombie behavior can be inconsistent (eerie at best, annoying to predict at worst), and while Torn Banner has fixed most of the Early Access bugs, technical issues and controller problems still linger enough that mouse-and-keyboard remains the safe choice. The map count at 1.0 is also still thin.
The art and sound design are the whole horror engine, and they're excellent — dark, oppressive, and committed to selling emptiness and dread over spectacle. It's undercut by the technical side: performance hitches and the lingering jank that survived Early Access. Torn Banner has already committed to multiple 2026 updates with more content and fixes, so the trajectory is firmly upward.
The atmospheric and survival design is genuinely special — a co-op horror experience with no real equal in mood. Dragged down by weak core gunplay and technical rough edges that a game this tense deserves to be free of.
Twenty-nine hours with a regular squad and the tension hasn't dulled — the emergent survival stories are the replay engine, and the new Survival mode adds a shorter-session option. With committed post-launch support and more maps promised, this is a number that should climb. It holds like the best co-op games do: on the friends and the stories, not the checklist.
Herd approved, both nostrils holding their breath. If you have a squad and want the most nerve-shredding co-op zombie survival on the market, this is it — just go in knowing the shooting is the weak link and a little jank remains. As a comeback story, it's one of the year's best: proof that a botched launch doesn't have to be a death sentence. We're thrilled to Re-Sniff this one upward.
Fresh verdicts the herd sniffed out recently.
The gunplay still hits and the gore is glorious — but after nearly seven hours, this feels like a leaner, live-service-flavored shadow of Killing Floor 2. A solid Early Access launch wearing a full-price coat.
The best co-op chaos machine of its generation — a satire of fascist space patriotism where the friendly fire is the punchline and the point.
A cheap, scrappy Resident Evil 2 tribute with one real trick up its sleeve: you have fifteen minutes to live, and dying is how you learn the map. It wears its influences on its sleeve and its bugs on its face, but the loop makes failure feel like progress — a rare thing in the genre.
One email a week. New reviews, no slop.